March 6, 2017 by Sandra Steingard, MD
Letter to my Classmates on our 40th Reunion
My college publishes a book for each class celebrating a five year reunion. We are invited to submit an essay. This is mine.
A few years ago, someone sitting in my office looked up at the diplomas on my wall and said, “You went to Harvard? I didn’t know you were smart!”
I mention that not only to brag about how stealth I am with keeping any bit of intelligence I might possess under wraps but also to acknowledge — before I launch into what may seem like a rant — that I understand that I have benefited in small and big ways from my Harvard education.
February 21, 2017 by Sandra Steingard, MD
Farewell Mickey Nardo, 1 (not very) Boring Old Man
About five years ago, as my own blogging life was beginning, I found John M. Nardo’s outstanding blog, www.1boringoldman. His focus was on the poor quality of studies that formed the evidence base of modern psychiatry. In a painstaking way, he dove into study after study and pointed out their flaws. His outrage was apparent but couched in a graceful eloquence.
There was a comment section and I eventually jumped in. I had some communication with him outside of the blog, but mostly our communication was in the comments. At the beginning, I did not know his name or much about him. Over time, he shared a bit of his story.
February 20, 2017 by Sandra Steingard, MD
Committed: The Battle Over Involuntary Psychiatric Care
Dinah Miller and Annette Hanson are two of the three psychiatrists who blog at Shrink Rap. After I started blogging, I began to search out other blogging psychiatrists and I found them. They also have articles published in Clinical Psychiatry News. My impression is that they are decent, well-meaning, and thoughtful psychiatrists (not unlike most of the psychiatrists I know) who want to demystify our profession. Their writing is clear, straightforward, and accessible. Like me, they are all practicing psychiatrists and they deal with the pragmatic challenges we face in our daily work. They offer critical views but they overall seem proud of their profession and their careers. While I respect their work, in that area we seem to differ; they do not seem to be burdened by the professional existential angst that besets me.
On one topic we agree — the subject of involuntary care is the most vexing, contentious, and troubling topic for psychiatry. To their great credit, they have directed an enormous amount of attention and effort to this subject in their latest book, Committed: The Battle Over Involuntary Psychiatric Care.
February 6, 2017 by Sandra Steingard, MD
Sir Robin Murray and Our Collective Mea Culpa
Sir Robin Murray, a distinguished British professor of psychiatry, recently published a paper in Schizophrenia Bulletin titled, “Mistakes I Have Made in My Research Career.” He describes the evolution of his thinking regarding the concept of schizophrenia, including the problems with the neurodevelopmental model, the limitations of the drugs used to treat the condition, and his failure to pay adequate attention to the role of social factors in the etiology of psychotic states. These ideas are not new to anyone who has read Anatomy of an Epidemic. Sir Robin’s ’s paper could be read as a synopsis of Chapter 6, “A Paradox Revealed.”
January 9, 2017 by Sandra Steingard, MD
Creating lives of meaning
The era when I was a young physician was one of great optimism for science and medicine. We were still riding on the advances made through the discovery of lifesaving antibiotics and the unraveling of our genetic code. We thought it was just a matter of time before most diseases would be conquered.
December 7, 2016 by Sandra Steingard, MD
Vermont Collaborative Network Approach Launched
I have had the great privilege and pleasure of working with a group of colleagues in Vermont who share my interest in bringing the humble and democratic ways of working developed in northern Finland and Norway to our state. Many of us were introduced to this work by Robert Whitaker’s description of Open Dialogue in Anatomy of an Epidemic and Daniel Mackler’s documentary Open Dialogue, and some of us worked with Tom Anderson, who came to Vermont in the 90s.
Some had traveled to Europe to attend the annual meeting of the International Network for the Treatment of Psychosis, the group of clinicians who had been working in this way for the past two decades. Others had the opportunity to train with Mary Olson, PhD at the Institute for Dialogic Practice. We have formed study groups and developed small teams who are beginning to introduce this way of working to our clinics.
November 22, 2016 by Sandra Steingard, MD
Moving ahead in troubled times
The Foundation for Excellence in Mental Health Care was founded in 2011 with the hope of expanding what many had come to believe was a narrow and faulty understanding of psychiatric conditions.
April 18, 2016 by Sandra Steingard, MD
My Journey of Recovery
I was recently asked to write an article for SAMHSA’s Recovery to Practice newsletter. This is a slightly edited version of that post.
Let me be clear: I was never anti-recovery. I will admit, however, that when the recovery movement first came to my attention in the 1990s, I was not drawn in. Whenever I attended a presentation on the topic, rather than being able to listen openly to the speaker, I felt defensive. At the time, I was working in a state that was pushing hard to close its state psychiatric hospital. While the mantra was of recovery, it seemed to be promoted by fiat. Since people were expected to recover, therefore, we did not need a state hospital.
February 28, 2016 by Sandra Steingard, MD
Testifying in Vermont: Forced Drugs
Vermont is a wonderful state and I am privileged to call it my home. We are known for our progressive ways, and this extends to our mental health care system. However, there are intense disagreements here – as there are everywhere – and I have learned in recent years about how changes that seem positive can have unexpected consequences.
In 2011, our state hospital closed suddenly over the course of a 24 hour period when it was flooded during Hurricane Irene.
December 15, 2015 by Sandra Steingard, MD
Book Review – Psychiatry Reconsidered: From Medical Treatment to Supportive Understanding
Psychiatrists around the world are currently engaged in efforts to critique the profession. Concern about the expansion of diagnostic terminology, the overly zealous use of pharmacotherapy, and the incursion of commercial interests – specifically by the pharmaceutical industry – into the workings of the profession are among the areas of concern.
Many psychiatrists have come to a critical stance after years in practice. But each year, newly minted doctors join the profession. They are trained in a system that tends to reify concepts that demand more critical scrutiny. It is a challenge to formulate a way of educating them about the generally accepted body of knowledge of the field while simultaneously instilling a critical appreciation of the limits of our understanding and therapeutic capabilities.
Hugh Middleton, the co-founder of the Critical Psychiatry Network, has written a remarkably eloquent yet concise book that fills this niche. “Psychiatry Reconsidered: From Medical Treatment to Supportive Understanding.”